Skeptic Radar – Market Place
Posted by Don McLenaghen on February 6, 2011
During a previous episode of RFT, I made a comment about the CBC consumer advocacy show Market Place and a segment they did about water purifier scams (“Clean water, Dirty tricks”). I had ‘lost my voice’ at the time I had made these comments and wanted clarify my points more clearly now.
First, I like Market Place in general and thought their segment on the water filter scams informative
and well done. I did want to make the point that as good skeptics we should not fall into complacency even when the source of info is from an authority we respect and thought this episode an opportunity to help illuminate and educate skeptics on what to keep your eyes open for when watching ANY documentary.
To make this point I noted two skeptic weaknesses – precipitates and chlorination.
They showed that purification sellers use a chemical “trick” to make water seem dirtier than it “really” was. Now it was true that the claims of health risks made by the sellers were horribly over stated but… Yes, the skeptic “BUT”…where they completely baseless? Market Place explained that normal water has minerals dissolved into it AND that these minerals are harmless. Now I accept as uncontroversial the first part but the second part MAY have been an over generalization. It is possible, depending on the water source and distribution, that some of the precipitate could have been deleterious to health (such as arsenic or cadmium both of which are harmful). They could have easily been ‘skeptic proof’ by adding the statement akin to “Now unless there is a special reason to suspect these precipitates (such as unexplained health ailments) most people should not worry about them and definitely not the cause for extreme panic the water seller made it sound”
The other item that twitched my skeptic radar was the line about chlorination. Water agents over stated the dangers of chlorine used as a disinfectant by municipal purification plants. This was countered by Market Place stating that chlorine at the municipal level was necessary to kill bacterial agents, which is true. However, I was not convinced that once the water hits your taps the same risks of infection are present; that de-chlorinating my water at the tap posed the same health risks as not chlorinating at the plant. Further, they missed the point that a badly maintained home filtration system can itself be a bastion for “toxic” bacteria.
Again, love Market Place but thought this episode had some good skeptic teaching points.
This entry was posted on February 6, 2011 at 9:35 pm and is filed under Blogs, Don's Blogs. Tagged: Argument from authority, authority, bacterial agent, chlorination, Clean water, Dirty tricks, Market Place, municipal purification plant, precipitate, scam, sceptic, scepticism, skeptic, skeptic proof, skeptic teaching point, Skepticism, water purification, water purifier scams. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.